Showing posts with label Critic's Manifesto. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Critic's Manifesto. Show all posts

Thursday, May 1, 2008

Critic's Manifesto: Amanda Mull

On the surface, a critic exists to tell readers if something is good or bad. Simple. There are characteristics that either make a movie, a performance and a meal successful or unsuccessful, and it's a critic's job to evaluate the finished product and share their findings with the public.

But, as with most things, it's never that simple.

Sure, critics are charged with deciding what's good and what's bad. But if that's all a critic did, he or she would probably toil in obscurity forever. The best critics are able to take a work and explain why or how it fits into culture. Whether or not a piece of art is good may be interesting, absolutely, but not nearly so interesting as what a particular piece of art may say about the culture that created it.

The job of a critic is to help us understand how art, food, and entertainment in general fit into our lives and reflect on our tastes, ideals, and views as a society. A critic's purpose is not just to tell you that "Shot at Love with Tila Tequila" is a terrible television catastrophe; most people could figure that out on their own after 30 seconds of viewing. Instead, a critic should tell you why it's interesting that the show is back for a second season, despite the fact that everyone that has ever encountered it agrees that it's terrible.

Whether something is good or not is almost besides the point.

Yet Another Critic's Manifesto

By Steven Carter

There are so many negative connotations that accompany the word critic because too many jaded writers get paid too much to bash what they could never create.

The critic judges the quality of a particular form of entertainment, and their primary role is to inform people of the great things that they may otherwise miss.

Some critics (like book naysayer Michiko Kakutani of the New York Times) believe that their job description entails beating a dead horse until its insides come oozing out. As an aspiring novelist/ poet, it infuriates me to see terrible writers writing about how others can’t write well.

A good critic should never focus primarily on telling people what to avoid [because Americans naturally avoid most forms of art anyway, and don‘t appreciate the ones they do embrace (just look at the Billboard charts or listen to the latest pop compilation, Now 87, featuring the newest recycled beats along with teenage pop-stars undertaking their long arduous journey to rehab)].

A good critic should provide suggestions for the reader that will enhance their appreciation of a given medium. If I happen to hear a great band or read a great author, I’ll tell my friends. I’ll let them borrow the book or burn some CD's for them. And if I hear a band that blows (name drops are so tempting right here), I won’t sit there and waste an hour telling my friend how bad it is. I won’t rattle off a list of names to avoid because that negativity adds nothing to someone‘s life. There are plenty of terrible movies, albums, and books out there (that always manage to take negative reviews out of context to fool the consumer). I don’t see any reason to even acknowledge them in the first place.

As a critic (a title I’ll assume for this manifesto), it’s not my job to filter through the trash and smear more filth on something not worth picking up in the first place. It’s my job to find the great works that may slip through the cracks and throw them on top of the heap where they can’t be ignored.

Being a critic is about giving people a chance to appreciate new, exciting things. And I can’t think of anything more positive than that.

A Critic's Manifesto


The word "critic" is a harsh one, calling to mind the words "criticize" and "complain" and so on.  Indeed, that is how I used to view critics - they were all negative know-it-alls who had never created anything a day in their lives.

Now that I have begun morphing into one, however, I can appreciate a new role for the critic, one that is far more endearing and earnest.

Because there is not enough time in the day for all of us to explore every cultural opportunity available, the critic must be ready to create a representation through words that is worthy of the piece.  People create art for a reason, and it should be discussed and appraised.  The art deserves that respect, and the people deserve the joy and enlightenment that can come from it.  
I'd like my reviews to be beautiful, to be their own works of art worthy of those they discuss.  I'd like to write pieces that inspire thought and discussion in our society.  I do not claim that every piece I write will bring tears to the eyes of masses of readers everywhere, but I hope they will bring appreciation and understanding.  And maybe even entertainment.  

This is art, and we should have some fun.

The Role of the Critic

At the beginning of the semester, I said that a critic’s main purpose was to guide people. Time is finite and when you add up all the boring, unimportant stuff – work, family, sleep – there’s hardly anytime to watch Kung fu movies or listen to Soulja Boy. Therefore a critic needs to tell you the best way to enjoy your precious free time. Otherwise you might find yourself wasting it on crap.

As the semester has continued, I still have held on to my earlier notion. Yet I feel the critic has another role besides guiding people. They need to take on a personality through their reviews.

The critic is like a politician. In the political world, people give flip-floppers flak because no one has an idea of how they will react or judge something. The same is true of critics. We need critics who believe strongly in their own beliefs. A critic needs to judge work solely on who they are. By doing so readers know what the critic likes or dislikes. If the critic hates chick flicks, like he or she should, then the reader knows that they should seek advice elsewhere on whether a chick flick is good or not.

As the amount of art and entertainment increases at a feverish rate, the need for strong independent critics is at an all-time high. Whether critics will express themselves through text, audio or video in the future remains uncertain. The only certainty is that they are needed.

----Adam Lipper